Skip to content
Categories MLB

MLB Player Prop Bets & Home Run Pick Today for Sunday, May 12 (2024)

Updated May 12, 2024 | 10:31 am CDT by Brett Ford

Happy Mother’s Day! All 15 MLB teams are in action, starting at 1:35 p.m. ET, so celebrate all the moms in your life by wagering on a pair of player props and one bet from our +EV betting tools I’ve been using to build the bankroll for the last few weeks, you can get them for 50% off — keep scrolling to see the exclusive coupon code!

Looking for more sports betting picks and analysis? Check out our home run betting strategy may be of assistance.

MLB Player Prop Bets & Home Run Pick Today: Sunday, May 12

React App

MLB Player Prop Bet Today: Josh Lowe

The Tampa Bay Rays have been one of the most aggressive teams in the MLB on the basepaths this season, stealing an American League-high 47 bags. Built for speed more than power, the Rays will look to take advantage of whichever New York Yankees catcher they face on Sunday, either Austin Wells or Jose Trevino. Though we’d prefer to see Trevino for stolen base purposes, the Rays won’t be shy to run against either catcher.

Trevino ranks 65th among all catchers in pop time, averaging 2.06 seconds, and has caught just three runners attempting to take second base this season. Wells is only slightly better with a 1.96 pop time and has caught just one runner in nine stolen base attempts. In five games against the Yankees this season, Tampa Bay has combined to steal nine bases, including one against today’s starting pitcher, Luis Gil. The Rays aren’t afraid to run and should be looking to swipe bags early and often today.

Josh Lowe returned from the injured list on Monday and has yet to attempt a stolen base, but fresh off a full day of rest yesterday, he’s poised to get moving on the basepaths Sunday. Lowe swiped a career-high 32 bases last season and was caught just three times, showcasing some excellent speed and good baserunning skills. Listed at +520 on FanDuel, Lowe’s odds are just too darn high to up.

Though Lowe hasn’t taken off yet this season, he was one of the most prolific base stealers in the league last year. His long odds and potential to run in this matchup make him an ideal bet for Sunday’s action.

MLB Player Prop Pick Today: Josh Lowe Over 0.5 Stolen Bases (+520 at FanDuel)


MLB Betting Model Pick Today: Matt Carpenter

What year is it? Well, we said the same things a couple of years ago when Carpenter exploded for 15 home runs in just 128 at-bats with the New York Yankees. Now Carpenter is back where he began his career, with the St. Louis Cardinals. He earned his first start since April 1 on Saturday and finished 2-for-4 with a double. Today our model suggests that he’ll leave the yard against the Milwaukee Brewers. OddsShopper’s positive expected value (+EV):

As the model shows, the +540 at FanDuel is far and away the best odds offered on Carpenter’s home run prop this afternoon. No other public books list this bet for any better than +460, creating an 80-cent discrepancy, while the true odds are +438.

So how does our model draw that conclusion? It draws in the odds from across the sports betting market; adjusts for hold, book sharpness and other factors; then generates a breakeven price (called “true odds”) for each bet.

Over a large sample, bets like this one will transform your bankroll. Not every bet will win, but we have the results and back-tested simulations to show our model is worth it.

For the rest of our tools’ picks, subscribe to promo code “POSITIVE” to get your first week or month for 50% off (the regular prices are $14.95 and $49.95)!

MLB Betting Model Pick: Matt Carpenter to Hit a Home Run (+540 at FanDuel)


MLB Home Run Pick Today: William Contreras

The Milwaukee Brewers will finish off their series against their division rival St. Louis Cardinals on Saturday. With a victory today, the Brewers would complete a four-game sweep of the Cardinals and extend their lead in the NL Central. Miles Mikolas takes the mound for St. Louis looking to help the Cardinals snap a seven-game losing streak.

William Contreras will likely bat in the top third of the order against Mikolas, hoping to tee off against the veteran pitcher. Contreras has gone 4-for-9 in his career against Mikolas, including a double, but we’re looking for him to leave the yard today. Mikolas has given up eight home runs in 42.0 innings, one of the highest HR/9 rates in the MLB among pitchers with at least 30 innings this season.

Contreras hasn’t left the yard since April 25, but his 41.2% hard- rate ranks third among qualified hitters across the MLB. Contreras has evolved into one of the elite hitters in the MLB, and with his +400 odds against a homer-prone pitcher, we have to jump on that line.

MLB Home Run Pick Today: William Contreras To Hit a Home Run (+400 at FanDuel)

React App

OddsShopper’s MLB Tools & Tips

Looking for more 2024 MLB predictions? market-based betting model’s picks and best bets.

Categories MLB
Best Caitlin Clark Bet: Hammer This WNBA Future While The Value Is Here
Best OwnersBox Promo Code Today
Avatar

Author

Brett Ford

A freelance writer with Stokastic and OddsShopper, Brett Ford brings a decade of experience working in college and professional sports to the team.

Next Story

EVEN MORE Stories of Bankroll Building with Portfolio EV — Plus 50% Off Your Next Month!

Trending & Related

MLB Home Run Pick Today for April 22: Let’s Go Off the Beaten Bath for a Bomb…

NRFI Bets Today: Best No Run First Inning Picks for Tuesday, April 22

MLB Home Run Pick Today for April 20: Special Giveaway Tomorrow If We Get This Tater …

Betting 101

What is Portfolio EV? Guide to +EV Sports Betting

Positive Expected Value Explained: How to Find Positive EV Edges in Sports Betting

Why the Sportsbooks Hate You When You Actually Start Winning

Sports Betting Software Showdown: Which Tool Is Right for You?

Sports Betting Resources

  • Positive EV NFL Bets
  • Expert NFL Picks
  • Live NBA Odds
  • Positive EV NBA Bets
  • Expert NBA Picks
  • Live NFL Odds
  • NFL Parlay Calculator
  • Positive EV MLB Bets
  • Expert MLB Picks
  • Positive EV College Football Bets
  • Expert College Football Picks

Featured Articles

EVEN MORE Stories of Bankroll Building with Portfolio EV — Plus 50% Off Your Next Month!
June 2, 2025 3:10 pm | Sam Smith
How Bettors Used Portfolio EV to Beat the Books in May
June 1, 2025 12:56 pm | Sam Smith
Why the Sportsbooks Hate You When You Actually Start Winning
May 20, 2025 2:17 pm | Dave Loughran
What is Dinger Tuesday? How to Beat FanDuel’s Promotion
May 20, 2025 2:10 pm | Isaiah Sirois
How Portfolio EV Built My NBA Bankroll from $100 to $1,200
May 16, 2025 7:11 am | Greg Ehrenberg
You Don’t Need to Be a Genius to Beat the Books — Just the Right Tools
April 26, 2025 8:15 am | Dave Loughran

Related Articles

MLB Betting Strategy: 5 Tips for Winning on MLB Betting Sites
June 5, 2025 1:56 pm | Dave Loughran
MLB Home Run Betting Strategy: How to Profit on Home Run Bets
June 5, 2025 11:52 am | Isaiah Sirois
Underdog Fantasy Pick’em Predictions Today: Pablo Lopez (June 3)
June 3, 2025 12:25 pm | Danny Burke
FREE First MLB Portfolio on Portfolio EV: A Step-by-Step Guide
May 29, 2025 11:56 am | Sam Smith
MLB Betting: What are NRFI & YRFI Bets? First Inning Bets Explained
April 23, 2025 7:25 am | Justin Martin
How to Bet on MLB Strikeout Props: Strategy & Expert Advice
April 23, 2025 7:25 am | Isaiah Sirois

Best Sleeper Promo Code Today
June 7, 2025 6:42 am
Best Underdog Promo Code Today
June 7, 2025 6:42 am
Best ParlayPlay Promo Code Today
June 7, 2025 6:42 am
How Do I Make Money Sports Betting? Portfolio EV, Of Course
June 6, 2025 11:00 am
MLB Betting Strategy: 5 Tips for Winning on MLB Betting Sites
June 5, 2025 1:56 pm
What is Portfolio EV? Guide to +EV Sports Betting
June 5, 2025 11:54 am
MLB Home Run Betting Strategy: How to Profit on Home Run Bets
June 5, 2025 11:52 am
Get a 7-DAY FREE TRIAL Of Portfolio EV Today!
June 5, 2025 11:50 am
Positive Expected Value Explained: How to Find Positive EV Edges in Sports Betting
June 5, 2025 11:45 am
Underdog Fantasy Pick’em Predictions Today: Chet Holmgren (June 5)
June 5, 2025 9:01 am

How Can I Find the Best Sports Betting and DFS App Bonuses?

If you're a new sports bettor, it's hard to know where to start. In fact, it's simpler than it seems, because there are use OddsShopper's Free Bet Converter to maximize your beginning bankroll

Get a bonus code for BetMGM

Get a promo code Caesars Sportsbook

Best DraftKings Promo Code

Get a promo code for DraftKings

Use a promo code for FanDuel

Claim a promo code for PrizePicks

Get a promo code for UnderDog

the ranks of the OddsShopper Hall of Fame

  • Free Expert Picks

    • Free NBA Picks
    • Free MLB Picks
    • Free NFL Picks
    • Free NHL Picks
    • Free NCAAB Picks
    • Free NCAAF Picks
    • Free Golf Picks
    • Free UFC Picks
    • Free EPL Picks
    • Free Tennis Picks
    • Free WNBA Picks
  • Positive EV Bets

    • Positive EV NBA Bets
    • Positive EV MLB Bets
    • Positive EV NFL Bets
    • Positive EV NHL Bets
    • Positive EV NCAAB Bets
    • Positive EV NCAAF Bets
    • Positive EV Golf Bets
    • Positive EV UFC Bets
    • Positive EV EPL Bets
    • Positive EV Tennis Bets
    • Positive EV WNBA Bets
  • Betting Tools

    • Arbitrage Opportunities
    • Parlay Builder
    • PrizePicks Entry Builder
    • Underdog Entry Builder
    • Sleeper Entry Builder
    • Free Bet Converter
  • Articles

    • All Articles
    • NBA Articles
    • NFL Articles
    • NCAAF Articles
    • MLB Articles
    • PGA Articles
    • NHL Articles
    • NASCAR Articles
    • MMA Articles
  • Betting Calculators

    • Expected Value Calculator
    • Hold Calculator
    • Parlay Calculator
    • Odds Converter
  • Live Odds

    • Live NBA Odds
    • Live MLB Odds
    • Live NFL Odds
    • Live NHL Odds
    • Live NCAAB Odds
    • Live NCAAF Odds
    • Live Golf Odds
    • Live UFC Odds
    • Live EPL Odds
    • Live Tennis Odds
  • Sportsbook Promo Codes

    • BetMGM Bonus Codes
    • Bet365 Bonus Codes
    • FanDuel Promo Codes
    • DraftKings Promo Codes
    • Caesars Promo Codes
    • BetRivers Promo Codes
    • Sleeper Fantasy Promo Codes
    • Underdog Fantasy Promo Codes
    • Betr Picks Promo Codes

    • Us
    • of Use
    • Stokastic
OddsShopper Logo
© 2024 Stokastic.All Rights reserved.
This site contains commercial content, We may be compensated for the links provided on this page. The content on this page is for informational purposes only. OddsShopper makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy of the information given or the outcome of any game or event. Please play responsibly. Only customers 21 and over are permitted to play. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem and wants help, call 1-800-GAMBLER.